HB: Permanent Injury

2d6	Injury	Effect
2	Lost Limb	Snake Eyes! A savage strike to your body cleaves a part straight off. Choose which part. (And no, it can’t be the tip of your pinky.)
3	Hand Tremors	Don’t apply Proficiency Bonus to attacks with two-handed weapons and Dual-Wielding attacks.
4	Shattered Body	Max HP permanently reduced by 10%.
5	Crushed Leg	Speed reduced by 5 ft. Dashing Speed reduced by 5 ft. as well.
6	Concussion	Roll Concentration Checks with Disadvantage, or without your Proficiency Bonus. Choose one.
7	Horrific Scar	You are visibly marked. Gain advantage on Intimidation and disadvantage on Persuasion.
8	Psychological Trauma	Choose a trigger connected to the near-death event. Exposure requires a Hard WIS Save or become Frightened for up to three rounds, making a new Hard WIS Save at the end of each of your turns.
9	Lost Fingers	Fine manipulation is harder. Slight of Hand and tool checks at disadvantage
10	Night Terrors	Roll an Easy Wisdom Save every Long Rest. Failure wakes you up screaming, with one level of Exhaustion.
11	Crushed Eye Socket	Don’t apply Proficiency Bonus to ranged attacks and Perception checks.
12	Miraculous Survival	You escape death with only a symbolic scar. You’re convinced it’s divine intervention. Receive Heroic Inspiration if you regale the story of your miraculous survival to a new audience (without them shutting you down).

Snake Eyes!

Let the Player think about what they want to lose